Thursday, December 13, 2007

Finally, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame has some credibility


The latest inductees were named today. Madonna, Mellencamp, the Dave Clark Five, Leonard Cohen, and the Ventures are the main recipients. The Dave Clark Five? Jesus Christ. One big hit and no lasting cultural impact. The rest I'm OK with (full disclosure: I own some Madonna CDs). All of the recipients were also named steroid users and HGH devotees. Oh wait. That was THIS list!

8 comments:

Andrew said...

Easy Dave! According to what appears to be the official band website, DC5 were not only the first British band (ever?) to tour the US, but also the first British band (ever?) to have a private plane, and even had a DC5 logo on the side of said plane. Thus, not only did DC5 spearhead the British invasion, they may have (more importantly) provided the inspiration for the TCB-Flash logo on Elvis's plane. Sounds like HOF material to me.

Dave said...

I consider myself schooled. Still, I think only 3/5 of the Five deserve it. Plus, as a musician, the idea of a lead vocalist drummer is repugnant.

Jay said...

I would also question Madonna's inclusion in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, Dave. Madonna? Rock 'n' roll? Give me a fucking break.

But then, I would also question the inclusion of Miles Davis and Grandmaster Flash. Innovative? Check. Iconic? You betcha. Rock 'n' roll? Not so much.

I know, I know, it's a slippery slope, but geez ...

Mike said...

Here's my yearly "it really ain't a hall of fame at all it's just a modern music museum" speach:

Ah fuck it, I think I'll just roll my eyes and move on. I'm still peeved it's in flippin Cleveland.

Dave said...

Yeah, totally agree with Madonna being a strange choice. It definitely does start make it into a pop music museum. Pat Benatar would have been a much better choice.

Mike said...

For those that care, the player list from the Mitchell report:

http://www.ajc.com/sports/content/sports/braves/stories/2007/12/13/Mitchell_1214.html

None of us are on there. I already looked.

Joe said...

I FUCKING LOVE Pat Benetar! And let's not forget the the RnRHOF snubbed me not so long ago.

So they suck.

Joe said...

I also FUCKING LOVE Pat Benatar, but that's another story.